My family and I were on vacation in Gatlinburg and decided to travel up to Pigeon Forge to see if we could find a barbeque restaurant to check out. I spotted a Corky’s that I really wanted to eat at, but up the road a bit was a restaurant called Bennett’s Pit Bar-B-Que and out front was a sign that said, “voted best ribs in the county 2009”. Well, with an invitation like this, I just had to stop in and see for myself.
Bennett’s had the appearance and feel of a Sonny’s, but with more of a sports flare. There was NASCAR memorabilia on the walls, as well as, down home furnishings.
Bennett’s menu was loaded with lots of unique southern options such as fried green tomatoes and fried pickles from which to choose. The entrees were also enticing, ranging from baby back ribs as to spare ribs, beef brisket, steaks and chicken too.
Bennett’s BBQ sauce was sweet tomato based BBQ sauce that tasted good.
I ordered up the smokehouse combo which consisted of half slab of baby back ribs, a quartered chicken, and pulled pork served with beans and corn on the cob.
The food arrived hot, but the first thing I noticed was the portion size. My order of a half slab of ribs looked more like a quarter portion and the chicken piece they served me looked like it came from a Cornish game hen-it was so small!
The manager came up and ask how everything was and I told him my disappointment in the portion sizes that I was served. He told me that a rib cut with four bones to it was considered a half slab. Of course, I disagreed and told him about my hobby of reviewing restaurants. This was the first establishment that I had visited with an explanation of four ribs equals a half slab. I also explained to him that his sign out front was the reason I was there and for the money I was paying, this was very disappointing. After our discussion he came back to the table with more ribs and chicken so I felt that he knew and agreed that the portions were too small.
Let me tell y’all something. I was a chef for 10 years and I do not complain at restaurants, I know how hard it is to run and work in a restaurant. If I don’t like it, I usually just don’t go back.
The ribs were no where near the best I’ve had. The chicken was served hot and moist, but I was disappointed in the ribs. After reading their sign out front I expected something really special and they were not!
I almost felt like the sign out front was some sort of tourist trap to get me in there and hey, hats off to them… it worked.
I give Bennett’s a 2.5 on the squeal meter
Pics are in the pic section.